Grounds for and Legal Consequences of Revocation of Donation

Zurab Dzlierishvili

Abstract


The article provides the analysis of the legal grounds for revocation of donation like grievous insult or gross ingratitude on the part of the donee towards the donor or close relatives thereof or donor's falling in such financial straits after then donation when he is no more in the position to support himself or the persons dependent on him. The paper also offers the analysis of legal consequences of revocation of donation.


Keywords


revocation of donation for ingratitude on the part of the donee (Article 529 of the Civil Code of Georgia), re-vindication of donated thing (Article 530 of the Civil Code of Georgia).

Full Text:

PDF PDF (Georgian)

References


Constitution of Georgia, 24/08/1995.

The Civil Code of Georgia, 26/07/1997.

The Civil Procedure Code of Georgia, 14/11/1997.

Chachava S., Competition of Claim and Grounds for Claim in Private Law, Thesis Research, TSU, Tb., 2010, 83,85,87,89, 93, 162. (in Georgian).

Ciematniece I., Contract Renegotiation and Adaptation, Concept of Contract Renegotiation and Adaptation in International Commercial Law Contracts, Lambert Academic Publishing, Saarbrücken, 2010, 5.

Chitashvili N., The Effect of Changed Circumstances on Obligation Performance and Parties’ Possible Secondary Remedies, "Bona Causa", Tbilisi, 2015 (in Georgian).

Collins H., The Law of Contract, Cambridge University Press, New York, 2003, 216-217.

Dolidze I., Old Georgian Law, Tbilisi, 1953, 153 (in Georgian).

Dzlierishvili Z., Legal Nature of Contract on Transfer of Property under Ownership, Tbilisi, 2010, 242, 243,245,255,257,258. (in Georgian).

Dzlierishvili Z., Some Aspects of Civil Procedure Law, Tb., 2007, 6 (in Georgian).

Dzlierishvili Z., Fulfillment of Obligations, Tb., 2006, 5 (in Georgian).

Frick J.G., Arbitration and Complex International Contracts, Kluwer Law International, Schulthess, 2001, 36.

Gehrlein in Bamberger/Roth (Hrsg.) BGB Komm. 3. Aufl., §530, Rn. 4, Rn.8, §531, Rn.1, Rn.2., §532, Rn.7.

Hoppenz in Prutting,Wegen, Weinreich (Hrsg.), BGB Komm. 2006, §531, Rn.1, Rn.2.

Koch in MüKo, BGB, Band 3, 5.Aufl., §516, Rn.3,Rn.6. §528, Rn.3., §529, Rn.3.,§530, Rn. 1., Rn. 3., §531, Rn.2, Rn.4., §532, Rn.2, Rn.4.

Krauss, Der Ruckforderungsanspruch wegen Verarmung des Schenkers im Kontext des Sozialhilferechts, ZEV 2001, 417.

Kropholler I., Educational Commentary to German Civil Code, Tb., 2014, 394 (in Georgian).

Kurdadze Sh., Khunashvili N., Civil Procedure Law of Georgia 2nd ed., Tbilisi, 2015, 168-169 (in Georgian).

Larenz, Wolf, Allgemainer Teil des Burgerlichen Rechts, 9.Aufl., 2004, §17, Rn.2., §18, Rn.15.

Liluashvili T., Civil Procedure Law, Tbilisi, 2005, 137 (in Georgian).

Recommendations of the Supreme Court of Georgia on Problematic Issues of Civil Law Judicial Practice, 2007, 63,64, 85,86, 87 (in Georgian).

Rundel, Ruckforderung wegen Verarmung des Schenkers bai mehreeren Beschenkten, Mitt-BayNot, 2003, 177.

Saenger in HK-BGB, 7.Aufl., 2013, 752- 756.

Seyfarth, Schenkungsruckforderung wegen Notbedarfs, 1998, 31ff.

Shengelia R., Shengelia E., Law of Inheritance, Tbilisi, 2011, 29 (in Georgian).

Schippers, Ruckforderungsanshpruch des verarmten Schenkers (§§ 528,529 BGB), RNotZ 2006, 42.

Szudik M., Reich durch Erbschaft und Schenkung? In: Reichtum und Vermogen, Wisbaden, 2009, 135.

Tonner, Schuldrecht, 3.Aufl.,2013, §14, 130,132-133.

Unberath in Bamberger, Roth (Hrsg.), Beck’scher Online-Kommentar zum BGB, 15. Aufl., 2009, §313, BGB.

Weidankaff in Palandt BGB Komm.67. Aufl. §529, Rn.1.ff., §530, Rn.6, Rn.8.

Wendtland in Bamberger, Roth (Hrsg.), BGB Komm. 3.Aufl. §130, Rn. 9.

Zeranski, Der Ruckforderungsanspruch des verarmten Schenkers, 1998, 21ff.

Zimmermann R., The Law of Obligations - Roman Foundations of the Civilian Tradition, Breach of Contract, Chapter 25, Clarendon, Oxford University Press, 1996, 792.

Zoidze B., Constitutional Control and Order of Values in Georgia, Tbilisi, 2007, 29 (in Georgian).

Новицкий И.Б., Перетерский И.С. (ред.), Римское частное право. М., 1999, 499 (in Russian).

Ruling of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of October 3, 2016 on Case: №AS-634-605-2016.

Ruling of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of May 25, 2016 Case №AS-290-276-2016.

Decision of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of April 15, 2016 on Case: №AS-157-153-2016.

Decision of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of March 18, 2016 on Case: №AS-1011-954-2015.

Ruling of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of February 17, 2016 on Case: №AS-910-860-2015.

Decision of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of November 20, 2015 on Case: №AS-471-450-2015.

Decision of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of September 22, 2015 on Case: №AS-710-676-2015.

Decision of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of July 24, 2015 on Case: №AS-887-848-2014.

Ruling of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of May 20, 2015 on Case: №AS-325-310-2015.

Ruling of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of April 30, 2015 on Case: №AS-482-456-2014.

Ruling of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of February 24, 2015 on Case: №AS-1235-1176-2014.

Ruling of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of December 8, 2014 on Case: №AS-482-456-2014.

Ruling of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of July 10, 2013 on Case: №AS-257-247-2013.

Ruling of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of January 12, 2012 on Case: №AS-1509-1517-2011.

Ruling of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of July 24, 2012 on Case №AS-221-213-2012.

Ruling of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of November 21, 2011 on Case: №AS-1275-1295-2011.

Ruling of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of October 24, 2011 on Case: №AS-1411-1426-2011.

Ruling of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of October 10, 2011 on Case: №AS-1124-1151-2011.

Decision of Civil Chamber of the Tbilisi Appeals Court of May 11, 2011 on Case: №2B-2002-2011.

Ruling of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of April 18, 2011 on Case: №AS-176-166-11.

Ruling of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of November 22, 2010 on Case: №AS-826-775-2010.

Ruling of the Civil Chamber of the Supreme Court of Georgia of June 14, 2010 on Case: №AS-385-358-2010.

Ruling of the Chamber of Civil, Company and Bankruptcy Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia of June 11, 2009 on Case: №AS-256-581-09.

Ruling of the Chamber of Civil, Company and Bankruptcy Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia of October 6, 2008 on Case: №AS-581-808-08.

Ruling of the Chamber of Civil, Company and Bankruptcy Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia ofJune 4, 2007 on Case: №AS-73-419-07.

Ruling of the Chamber of Civil, Company and Bankruptcy Cases of the Supreme Court of Georgia of July 10, 2006 on Case: №AS-195-617-06.

Decision of the Constitutional Court of Georgia of 01.04.2003 on Case: №1/2/155.

OLG Karlsruhe Urteil vom 09.09.1988- 10 U 32/38, NJW 1989, 2136.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.